How to Combine Your 401(k) and 403(b) into One IRA for More Options and Lower Costs

🚀 1. Introduction: The Solution to Fragmenting Your Retirement

If you’re like most professionals, you’ve changed jobs at least a couple of times. Every job change usually leaves a trace:

• A retirement account forgotten in the previous workplace.
• Maybe you have a 401(k) from your first tech company and a 403(b) from your position in education or nonprofit.

Having multiple fragmented accounts isn’t just an administrative clutter; it’s an expensive and limited strategy that limits your options. Retirement account consolidation isn’t just an option; it’s a smart financial move.

The most powerful and flexible solution for combining your 401(k) and 403(b) is a rollover to an Individual Retirement Account (IRA).

In this blog, we’ll explore step-by-step how to execute a 401(k) to IRA and 403(b) to IRA rollover safely, revealing the power of unlimited investment options and the peace of mind that comes with financial simplification. Our goal is to provide you with a roadmap to consolidate your retirement accounts wisely and optimize your tax strategy.

🧐 2. Understanding the Landscape of Accounts: 401(k), 403(b), and IRAs

To appreciate the benefits of rollover, we must first understand the accounts you are merging.

2.1. The Inherent Limitations of 401(k) and 403(b)

Both 401(k) (private sector) and 403(b) (nonprofits and educational entities) are excellent savings vehicles while employed, especially if they include a match from the employer. However, when you leave your job, these accounts have serious disadvantages that justify rollover to IRAs:

• Restricted Investment Menus: Employer plans often limit your options to a pre-approved list of mutual funds.
• High Administration Costs and Funds: Small or older plans may charge high administrative fees and utilize funds with high Expense Ratios (ER). 403(b)s in particular are historically known for offering expensive annuities.

2.2. The IRA Rollover: The Ultimate Investment Platform

Once you consolidate your funds into a rollover IRA, you unlock a world of possibilities:

                                                          401K                                                              IRA

Investment Options	Limited menu of mutual funds.	Unlimited access: stocks, bonds, low-cost ETFs, index funds, real estate (via Self-Directed IRAs).
Average Cost (ER)	High. The historical average is 0.85% or more.	Very low. You can choose index funds with 0.03% ER or even $0 in account maintenance fees.
Control	Maintained by the former employer/administrator.	100% control by you and your advisor.
Simplification	A separate statement for each job.	A single statement for all transferred retirement funds.

Real Example of Savings: The Power of Low Costs

Imagine you have $\$150,000 spread across an old 401(k) and 403(b) with an  average Expense Ratio of 0.90%.

• Annual Cost on old accounts: $\$150,000 \times 0.0090 = \$1,350$
• When rolling over to an IRA and choosing a low-cost index fund (ETF) with an ER of 0.05%:
• Annual IRA Cost: $\$150,000 \times 0.0005 = \$75$
• Immediate Annual Savings: $\$1,275$

Over 20 years at a conservative growth rate, the cumulative difference in the final value of the account can easily exceed tens of thousands of dollars. This is the fundamental reason for consolidating retirement accounts.

⚙️ 3. The Detailed Step-by-Step Guide to Consolidation

The process of moving your 401(k) to an IRA or 403(b) to an IRA is a tax-free event, as long as you follow IRS rules to the letter.

3.1. Eligibility: When can you do a Rollover?

The fundamental rule is that funds must be eligible for distribution. This occurs in the following scenarios:

1. Termination of Employment: This is the most common reason for termination. Once you leave the employer sponsoring the plan, the funds are rollovable.
2. In-Service Rollover: Some plans, especially those that allow participants to reach age 59.5, permit funds to be rolled over to an IRA even if the participant remains employed.

3.2. Danger! Choose Direct Rollover

This is the most crucial step, and it is where the most expensive mistakes are made. You should always demand a Direct Rollover.

Direct Rollover (RECOMMENDED)	The old plan administrator sends the funds (check payable to the new custodian) directly to your new Rollover IRA.	ZERO tax withholding. The transfer is invisible to the IRS. It’s the safest method for a rollover 401(k) to IRA.
Indirect Rollover (AVOID)	The administrator sends you a check in your name (personally).	The law requires the old plan to automatically withhold 20% of the total in federal taxes. You have exactly 60 days to deposit 100% of the amount (including the 20% they retained) into your new IRA. If you miss the deadline or don’t deposit the missing 20%, that amount is considered a taxable distribution and may be subject to the 10% early withdrawal penalty.

Advisor Tip: When calling your old trustee, use the precise language: “I need a direct rollover to an IRA rollover with my new custodian [Name of Custodian, e.g., Advise Financial, Vanguard, Fidelity].”

3.3. Opening the IRA Rollover

Open your new account before starting the process. The account is typically designated as a Traditional Rollover IRA.

1. Do your research, Custodians: Choose a custodian with a wide range of investment options, low (or no) account maintenance fees, and good customer service (e.g., online discount brokers).
2. Provide the Information: You will need to provide the old trustee with the name and address of the new custodian, as well as the IRA account number.

💰 4. Advanced Tax Implications: Traditional IRA or Roth IRA?

The most important decision after consolidating is how to handle the tax status of your money, especially if you’re considering a Roth IRA conversion.

4.1. Traditional Transfer (Tax-Deferred)

• 401(k)/403(b) Traditional to Traditional Rollover IRA: This is a non-taxable event. The money comes in with your pre-tax status, and taxes will be paid when the money is withdrawn in retirement.

4.2. The Roth Conversion Decision (The Taxable Dilemma)

• 401(k)/403(b) Traditional to a Roth IRA: This is called a Roth Conversion. It is a taxable event. The total amount transferred is added to your taxable gross income for the current year. You pay taxes now at your current marginal rate, but in return, future growth and all withdrawals in retirement will be 100% tax-free.

4.3. The Pro-Rata Rule Trap  (For Accounts with After-Tax Contributions)

This is the high-complexity section that differentiates your service. Some 401(k) or 403(b) plans allow after-tax contributions, other than Roth contributions.

If you have these after-tax contributions and want to make a Roth conversion and already have some balance in a traditional IRA, the IRS applies the Pro Rata Rule.

The Pro-Rata Rule: The IRS requires that, for conversion purposes, all of your Traditional IRAs (including Rollover IRAs, SEPs, and SIMPLE IRAs) be treated as a single aggregate account. You cannot simply choose to move the after-tax portion without also moving a proportionate portion of the pre-tax portion. This has the potential to complicate future Backdoor Roth strategies.

🛡️ 5. Special Considerations, Legal Risks, and Mistakes to Avoid

Before you sign the paperwork, you should be aware of the legal implications and exceptions that are lost with retirement account consolidation.

5.1. 401(k) Loans and the Spenddown

• The Risk: If you have an outstanding loan from your 401(k) or 403(b) and you roll over to an IRA, the remaining loan balance is immediately considered a taxable distribution (and the 10% penalty if you’re under age 59.5).
• The Solution: You must pay off the loan in full before you start the process of combining the accounts.

5.2. Creditor Protection: The “ERISA Advantage” of the 401(k)

This is a crucial consideration for high-net-worth individuals or in at-risk professions (doctors, lawyers, business owners).

• Employer Plans (401(k)/403(b)): Generally offer maximum protection against most creditors under the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). Assets are virtually shielded from lawsuits or judgments (with exceptions such as divorce QDROs or IRS debts).
• IRAs: Not covered by ERISA. Your protection against creditors is governed by State Law.
  • Federal Bankruptcy Protection: IRAs have strong federal protection in bankruptcy cases (with a monetary cap that adjusts for inflation, currently over $1.5 million).
  • Protection Outside Bankruptcy: This protection is varied. Some states fully protect IRAs, while others offer little to no protection against judgments and lawsuits.

Important: If asset protection is your primary concern, your advisor should weigh whether the flexibility and low costs of the IRA outweigh the strong legal protection of the old 401(k)/403(b) plan under ERISA.

5.3. Maintaining Access to the “55-Year Rule” Distribution

• Rule 55: Participants who leave a job at age 55 or older can withdraw money from that 401(k) (or 403(b)) plan without incurring the 10% early withdrawal penalty.
• The Loss: If you make the 401(k) rollover to IRA and you’re under age 59.5, you lose this exception on those funds. The 55-year-old exemption only applies to funds that remain in the employer’s plan.

❓ 6. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Consolidating Accounts

Is a rollover from 401(k) to IRA a “good idea” if I don’t need the money now?

Yes, it almost always is. The main goal is not to access money, but to increase the potential for long-term growth. By consolidating, you gain access to better investment options and eliminate the high fees that can erode your profits over time.

Can Roth 401(k) and Roth 403(b) accounts be combined into a Roth IRA?

Absolutely. If your employer plans include a Roth portion (funded with after-tax dollars), you can roll those funds into a Roth IRA tax-free and penalty-free. This helps you simplify and maintain the purity of your Roth funds.

How long does it take to complete retirement account consolidation?

The process of moving retirement funds can vary, but it usually takes between 2 and 8 weeks from the start of the application to the settlement of the funds in the new IRA. 403(b) plans with older annuities often take longer to settle due to their complex settlement structure.

Is there a limit to the amount of money I can roll over to an IRA?

No. Rollovers are not subject to annual contribution limits. You can roll over any amount from your eligible 401(k) or 403(b) to an IRA. The contribution limit only applies to the new money you deposit.

🔑 7. Conclusion: Your Path to a Simplified and Profitable Retirement

Consolidating your 401(k) and 403(b) into an IRA provides a unified view of your financial situation. Think of each of your retirement plan portfolios as a car that will take you to a specific destination—in this case, your retirement.

If you have 401(k) plans from multiple providers, it’s likely that, following our analogy, each car is different. What you’re looking for is the ideal car to take you to your independent retirement, not different vehicles that don’t work in a coordinated way under a solid plan.

It frees you from the constraints and costs of the past, giving you:

1. Total control over every dollar invested.
2. Access to Superior Investment Options (especially ETFs and low-cost index funds).
3. A drastic long-term cost reduction.

If you have retirement accounts from previous jobs, now is the time to put that money to work more efficiently for you. Don’t let high fees and fragmentation delay your retirement.

👉 Watch our quick VIDEO about 401(k)

👉 Register for our Webinar – “Roth Conversions: Minimize RMDs and Maximize Tax Efficiency”

👉 Schedule a call with our team of fee-only fiduciary advisors to create a personalized How to Combine Your 401(k) and 403(b) into One IRA for More Options and Lower Costs