For most investors, a falling market triggers an immediate gut reaction of stress and fear. Over the last few years, strong market returns have pushed retirement account balances to extraordinary highs for retirees and those preparing to retire.
Because of those gains, any pullback naturally triggers anxiety. You start wondering if this is finally the big crash market gurus have predicted for years. What if they’re actually right this time? Your mind starts racing through all the headlines: the risk of an AI bubble, the S&P 500’s heavy concentration in just a handful of tech companies, or how a stock like NVIDIA can suddenly drop for non-financial reasons completely outside any retiree’s control.
Despite the noise, if you’ve been a disciplined investor over the years, you already know the drill: as long as you hold a well-diversified portfolio built primarily on low-cost index funds or ETFs, you’ll be fine. You’ve learned that the worst thing you can do during a downturn is panic-sell, and that your main job is simply to rebalance your portfolio as asset classes drift from their target weights.
However, there is one proactive move you can make during a market drop that could potentially save you thousands, or even hundreds of thousands, of dollars in taxes, depending on the size of your portfolio. It is one of the primary strategies we recommend to our clients nationwide from our fee-only financial planning firm in Boca Raton, Florida:
Market downturns are a wonderful time (yes, you read that right, wonderful) to execute a Roth conversion, especially if you are retired or find yourself in a year with substantially lower taxable income.
How Does a Down-Market Roth Conversion Save You Money?
When you convert funds from a pre-tax Traditional IRA or 401(k) into an after-tax Roth IRA, the IRS taxes the dollar value of the transfer as ordinary income in the year of the conversion.
During a bear market or correction, two advantages work in your favor simultaneously:
- A “Tax Discount” on the Same Number of Shares: If you hold 1,000 shares of an index fund worth $100 per share ($100,000) and a 25% downturn drops the price to $75 per share ($75,000), converting all 1,000 shares reduces your taxable conversion income by $25,000.
- Tax-Free Rebound Growth: Once those 1,000 shares sit inside your Roth IRA, every dollar gained when the market recovers to $100 and compounds over the next decades grows completely tax-free.
Market Peak vs. 25% Downturn: Side-by-Side Tax Comparison
We put together a simple visual below so you can easily see the tax savings of doing a Roth conversion when the market is down. In this hypothetical example, we assume a 22% federal marginal tax bracket and a conversion of 1,000 shares of an equity fund:
Source: Advise Financial
As you can see, instead of paying $22,000 in taxes at the market peak, your tax bill for converting the same shares during a downturn drops to $16,500, saving $5,500 in taxes immediately.
A Massive Opportunity for Individual Tech & Growth Stocks
This strategy becomes even more powerful if you hold individual stocks that have taken a steep hit. Many clients who hire us on an hourly or retainer basis hold a large portion of their wealth in a single stock or a concentrated group of companies, such as Apple, Broadcom, Palantir, or NVIDIA.
In these cases, you can execute an “in-kind” Roth conversion, transferring the actual shares directly from your Traditional IRA into your Roth IRA without selling them first. You pay taxes on the depressed share price today, and when the stock eventually rebounds and grows over time, all of that future appreciation happens inside a completely tax-free account. It’s a true double benefit: a lower tax bill upfront and tax-free growth for life.
3 Additional Benefits of Converting During a Dip
Beyond lower upfront taxes, moving assets into a Roth IRA during a downturn strengthens your long-term retirement and estate plan:
- Lower Future Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs): Traditional IRAs force you to take taxable withdrawals starting in your 70s, which can push you into higher tax brackets whether you need the cash or not. Roth IRAs have zero RMDs for the original owner, giving you complete control over your retirement cash flow.
- Protection Against Higher Future Tax Rates: Paying taxes today while asset values are down locks in current tax rates, insulating your portfolio against future legislative tax increases. (Plus, for Florida residents, converting while domiciled in a state with zero state income tax avoids state-level tax drag altogether.)
- Tax-Free Inheritance for Heirs: Under the SECURE Act’s 10-year rule, non-spouse beneficiaries must empty inherited IRAs within a decade. Inheriting a Roth IRA allows your children or heirs to withdraw those funds completely income-tax-free during their peak earning years.
This third point is one I value tremendously. Sometimes clients ask me: “Wouldn’t it be better to skip Roth conversions, leave my investments alone, and let my heirs get a step-up in basis when I pass away so they don’t pay capital gains taxes?”
My answer is always the same: What happens the day after, or the year after, you pass away? If those stocks or index funds keep growing, your beneficiaries will owe taxes on all future gains when they sell. Moreover, a step-up in basis applies to taxable brokerage accounts, not pre-tax Traditional IRAs, which are taxed as ordinary income to your heirs. Leaving those assets in a Roth IRA lets your children keep that money compounding tax-free for up to 10 years, without paying a dime on dividends, interest, or capital gains, if they decide to restructure your retirement portfolio to fit their own financial goals.
5 Pitfalls That Can Turn a Roth Conversion Into a Costly Mistake
Because Roth conversions are irrevocable (the IRS no longer allows “recharacterizations” to undo a conversion), converting blindly during a market drop can backfire. Before initiating a transfer, watch out for these five common traps:
- Assuming Roth Conversions Are Simple Enough to DIY: A proper conversion strategy involves multiple moving parts: your tax brackets, asset location, how much to convert, and Medicare IRMAA thresholds. At Advise Financial, we help clients structure multi-year conversion campaigns so you know the exact dollar amount to convert each year and which accounts to draw from first.
- Triggering Medicare IRMAA Surcharges: Medicare premiums look back at your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) from two years prior. Exceeding an IRMAA threshold by even $1 can raise your Part B and Part D premiums for an entire year.
- Accidentally Bumping Into a Higher Tax Bracket: Converting too much at once can push the top portion of your conversion into the 24%, 32%, or 35% federal bracket, erasing the tax discount you got from the market dip.
- Paying Taxes From the IRA Itself: To maximize tax-free compounding, pay the conversion tax bill from cash in a taxable brokerage or savings account, not by withholding money from the IRA. If you are under age 59½, withholding taxes from the IRA also triggers a 10% early withdrawal penalty.
- Losing ACA Health Insurance Subsidies or Taxing Social Security: If you retire early and rely on an Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace health plan, added conversion income can wipe out thousands of dollars in premium tax credits. For many early retirees, optimizing ACA subsidies is one of the biggest factors determining whether they can comfortably afford to retire before age 65. Similarly, extra conversion income can make up to 85% of your Social Security benefits taxable.
Why Work With an Hourly, Fee-Only Financial Planner for a Roth Conversion?
You shouldn’t have to hand over 1% of your life savings every year in Assets Under Management (AUM) fees just to get a custom Roth conversion plan. In fact, traditional AUM advisors often face an inherent conflict of interest: pulling cash out of a managed portfolio to pay conversion taxes lowers the asset base they bill on.
Furthermore, there is a massive difference between a generalist advisor who rarely executes these transactions and a firm like Advise Financial, where we specialize in retirement tax strategies and process multiple Roth conversions every single month. Many financial advisors go their entire careers without ever executing a single Roth conversion. Think of it like knee surgery: you wouldn’t go to a general practitioner who has never operated on a knee; you’d go to a knee specialist.
At Advise Financial in Boca Raton, Florida, we solve both problems through a transparent hourly, fee-only fiduciary model at $300 per hour:
- Zero Conflicts of Interest: As a strictly fee-only fiduciary firm, Advise Financial never earns commissions, sells financial products, or charges ongoing asset percentages. Our only incentive is minimizing your lifetime tax bill.
- Transparent $300/Hour Pricing: A focused Roth conversion tax projection and multi-year bracket analysis typically takes just a few hours of dedicated planning. You pay only for the exact time required to build your roadmap, whether you meet with us locally in Boca Raton or virtually from anywhere in the U.S.
- Seamless CPA Coordination: We calculate your exact optimal conversion dollar amount well before the December 31 deadline so your CPA has clean, verified numbers come tax season. (Note: We are fiduciary financial planners, not CPAs, so we always recommend reviewing your final tax projections with your trusted accountant.)
Frequently Asked Questions About Down-Market Roth Conversions
Is it better to do a Roth conversion when the market is up or down?
It is mathematically better to do a Roth conversion when the market is down because depressed share prices let you convert the same number of shares for a lower taxable dollar amount. When the market rebounds, all subsequent gains grow tax-free inside the Roth IRA.
Can I undo a Roth conversion if the market drops even further?
No. Under current federal tax law, Roth conversions are irrevocable and cannot be recharacterized or undone. To manage the risk of further market drops, many investors convert in smaller tranches throughout the year rather than all at once. That said, few things are better in retirement than a nest egg growing completely tax-free inside a Roth IRA.
How much does an hourly fee-only financial planner charge for a Roth conversion analysis?
At Advise Financial in Boca Raton, Florida, we bill hourly fee-only fiduciary financial planning transparently at $300 per hour. A focused Roth conversion strategy, tax-bracket optimization, and Medicare IRMAA threshold review generally takes only a few hours, saving you thousands compared to ongoing 1% AUM advisor fees.
Ready to Run the Numbers on Your Portfolio?
Don’t let a market downturn go to waste, and don’t guess your way around IRS tax cliffs. Schedule a $300/hour consultation with Advise Financial in Boca Raton, FL (available in-person or virtually nationwide) to map out your optimal Roth conversion window before year-end.